What is Franklin Savings Association mean? Franklin Savings Association was an Ottawa, Kansas-based American Savings and loan association that was one of the largest seizures of the savings and loan crisis. Subsequent litigation established that the institution had always been in full capital compliance, a fact to which the FDIC stipulated in 2011, after 21 years of legal challenges by Franklin's shareholders. Also, the FDIC refused to open its books to a bankruptcy judge and never demonstrated that the seizure resulted in a loss to the American taxpayers. It is widely believed that Franklin's assets, which had a book value of more than $380 million when seized, were ultimately sold by the government to private investors at a significant profit.
Franklin Savings was founded in 1889. In 1972, Ernest Fleischer, became its largest shareholder. In 1981, a new business plan was developed for the thrift with the help of economics professor Wayne Angell who would go on to become a Federal Reserve Board governor, and its assets grew from $200 million to $11 billion. The thrift bought a large amount of mortgage-backed securities and had dealings in financial futures and interest rate swaps as part of a sophisticated risk hedging program that would come to be regarded in following years as state of the art. Franklin pioneered the practice of putting its portfolio through stress tests long before the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 would require such a practice of the nation's largest banks. They had various complex securities that included deep discounted securities, long call and put options and strips (both interest only and principal only) all of which were used for interest rate and prepayment risk hedging practices, not for speculation. They had also purchased junk bonds. The thrift had few traditional home mortgage loans on its books. The thrift's liabilities consisted primarily of Federal Home Loan Bank borrowings and repurchase agreements. In addition, over 70% of its deposits were obtained through brokers or telephone marketing programs, a method for raising deposits which U.S. District Judge Dale E. Saffels, a former Federal Home Loan Bank Board President, found at trial to be less expensive and more reliable than traditional deposits, despite Office of Thrift Supervision regulators' unsupported claims to the contrary. The thrift also bought the stock brokerage firms of L. F. Rothschild Holdings Inc., Stern Brothers & Company, and Underwood, Neuhaus & Company.
Franklin Savings was seized by the government in February 1990. At the time it had assets of $9.3 billion and deposits of $4.6 billion. Franklin filed a lawsuit disputing the seizure, and Judge Saffels in Topeka, Kansas ruled that the seizure was illegal. He found there was no basis in fact or law for the seizure, that it was arbitrary and capricious, and that, "there has been no allegation or even hint of illegal or unethical conduct by Franklin's management or directors. Essentially, this case boils down to a dispute over accounting practices." (Entire ruling attached.) Judge Saffels found that Franklin was in full capital compliance with a regulatory GAAP net worth of $388,519,213 and an economic value of no less than that.
However, the government appealed and the lower court's decision was reversed by the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit. Limiting its scope of review to the record presented by the OTS to justify the seizure, the court concluded that: "A review of the administrative file clearly reveals a high-flying, debt-laden, troubled savings and loan. The record reveals the owners diverting millions of dollars into their pockets through large salaries, bonuses and dividends, notwithstanding the losses being incurred by the association. The record reveals a financial institution taking what the director deemed to be unacceptable risks with its depositors' monies. In fact, the record reveals a financial institution both unable and unwilling to comply with the director's requirements relating to safety and soundness concerns."
The court arrived at this conclusion after determining that a court's role under FIRREA is limited to determining whether the statutory grounds existed for a seizure. The 10th Circuit concluded that, under FIRREA, the statutory grounds exist if in the Director's "opinion" they exist. The court went on to apply a dictionary definition of opinion: "a belief held with confidence, not substantiated by direct proof or knowledge."
The appeal became settled precedent for the post-seizure scope of judicial review for federally insured banks and thrifts after the United States Supreme Court declined to review the case.
In addition to losing on appeal before the 10th Circuit, Franklin's shareholders were denied hearings as a matter of law for their claims to recover the value of their holdings on either Takings (Claims Court and Federal Circuit) or Tort (District an reference
Full Form | Category |
Functional Service Architecture | Academic & Science |
Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries | Academic & Science |
Fellow, Society of Antiquaries | Academic & Science |
Fast Statistical Alignment | Academic & Science |
Finlands Automationssällskap rf | Academic & Science |
Finnish Society of Automation | Academic & Science |
Suomen Automaatioseura ry | Academic & Science |
Joyce E. Farrell IEEE Staff Award | Academic & Science |
Foundation Skills Assessment | Academic & Science |
Filipino Student Association | Academic & Science |
Federal Student Aid | Academic & Science |
Filipino Students Association | Academic & Science |
Faculty Student Association | Academic & Science |
Feeler S Architects | Academic & Science |
Federation of Schools of Accountancy | Accounts and Finance |
Financial Services Authority | Accounts and Finance |
Flexible Spending Arrangement | Accounts and Finance |
the Financial Services Authority | Business |
Financial Services Act | Business |
Financial Security Assurance Holdings, LTD. | Business |
Financial Security Assurance, Inc. | Business |
Flexible Spending Account | Business |
Field Service Advice | Business |
Four Swords Adventures | Business |
Fast Simulated Annealing | Business |
Firm-Specific Advantage | Business |
FSA Group Ltd | Business |
Financial Security Assurance | Business |
Financial Services Agency | Business |
Financial Service Authority | Business |
Fundamentals of Sustainability Accounting | Business |
Filemaker Solutions Alliance | Business |
Franklin Savings Association | Business |
Family Service Agency | Business |
Farm Security Agency | Business |
Formamidine Sulphinic Acid | Chemistry |
Friendly Society of Artists | Community |
Fire Safety Analysis | Community |
Fluid Sealing Association | Community |
Florida Standards Assessments | Community |
Fabless Semiconductor Association | Community |
Families Supporting Adoption | Community |
Florida Sheriffs Association | Community |
Florida Society of Anesthesiologists | Community |
Framework Study Areas | Computer and Networking |
Financial Services and Analysis | Computing |
Firewall Session Analyzer | Computing |
Full Screen Area | Computing |
Financial Security Assured | Computing |
Finite State Automaton | Computing |
Finite State Automata | Computing |
File System Adapter | Computing |
First Step Assistant | Computing |
First Service Application | Computing |
File Staging Area | Computing |
Free Software Association | Computing |
Finite State Automation | Computing |
Free Syrian Army | Country Specific |
File Sharing Application | Database Management |
Forward Sortation Area | General |
Future Slayers of America | General |
Field Scope Adaptor | General |
Food Services of America | General |
Fuel supply Agreement | General |
Flex Spending Account | General |
Faster Search Algorithm | General |
Flexible Savings Account | General |
File System Algorithms | General |
Flux Standard Action | General |
FCAT Sucked Air | General |
Foundational Skills Assessment | General |
Fuel Surcharge Adjustment | General |
FSA Digital Services | General |
Functional Support Agreement | General |
Future Search Assessment | General |
Fee Simple Absolute | General |
Facilitated Self Assistance | General |
Faggy Saggy Aggie | General |
Feed Safety Assurance | General |
Farm Sustainability Assessment | General |
Federal and State Aid | General |
Family Separation Allowance | General |
Full Steam Ahead | General |
Flying Saucer Attack | General |
Faculty Service Area | General |
Ford South Africa | General |
Front Shock Absorber | General |
Fleet Safety Awards | General |
Foton South Africa | General |
Ford South America | General |
Federal Crop Insurance Corporation | Governmental |
Farm Service Agency ( U. S. Department of Agriculture) | Governmental |
Freedom Support Act | Governmental |
Forest State Account | Governmental |
Family Support Act of 1988 | Governmental |
Field Security Advisor | Governmental |
Free Syria Army | Governmental |
Farm Service Agency | Governmental |
Farm Security Administration | Governmental |
Farm Service Association | Governmental |
Financial Standards Authority | Governmental |
Financial Services Association | Governmental |
Flexible Spending Accounts | Healthcare |
Friede Seiner Asche | International |
Fellow of The Society of Actuaries | Jobs |
Finite State Assumption | Maths |
Food Standards Agency | Medical |
Fire Support Area | Military and Defence |
Force Structure Allowance | Military and Defence |
Foreign Systems Acquisition | Military and Defence |
Full Speed Ahead | Military and Defence |
Fox Symes Australia | Regional |
Friends of South Africa | Regional |
Functionality, Speed, and Aesthetics | Softwares |
Fine Sun-pointing Acquisition Mode | Space Science |
Farmington Sports Arena | Sports |
Flatland Ski Association | Sports |