Prof disagrees with assigned textbook regarding an exam question

Course Queries Syllabus Queries 2 years ago

0 2 0 0 0 tuteeHUB earn credit +10 pts

5 Star Rating 1 Rating

Posted on 16 Aug 2022, this text provides information on Syllabus Queries related to Course Queries. Please note that while accuracy is prioritized, the data presented might not be entirely correct or up-to-date. This information is offered for general knowledge and informational purposes only, and should not be considered as a substitute for professional advice.

Take Quiz To Earn Credits!

Turn Your Knowledge into Earnings.

tuteehub_quiz

Answers (2)

Post Answer
profilepic.png
manpreet Tuteehub forum best answer Best Answer 2 years ago


This actually happened to my wife, but for the sake of simplicity I'll talk about it as if it happened to me.

I wrote a final exam for a university course last week, and a couple days ago I got my marks and the correct answers back. I disagreed with one of the questions I answered wrong, so I pulled out the textbook that was assigned to this course and found that it supports my answer. I sent an email to my prof with the page number and the exact quote from the textbook that supports my answer. His reply was (with slightly changed wording):

In class I said that correct exam answer... This is an issue with any text and shows why class is so vital: Texts rapidly go out of date or (such as the broad text used for this course) demonstrate a lack of depth. Lectures are usually much more up to date.

Keep in mind that this is an Archaeology class, which in my unprofessional opinion really doesn't "go out of date" all that quickly. The textbook is the assigned textbook for this course by the university. The online lecture notes posted by the prof make no mention of the disagreement. I was not present at the lecture.

Do professors have an obligation to recognize the assigned textbook as an authority in the context of the course? In my experience, when confronted with such a problem they typically go "Ok, fair enough, I'll give you the mark", but are they just being nice or are they supposed to do this? He's not a senior prof (not even PhD yet), so do you think going to his superior would help?

If I get this one extra mark it will bump me up 0.4 GPA for the course because I'm right at the cut-off.

Edit: Since several people asked, the question was something like "Which Aztec god is the god of war and is associated with water". The book said one god, Huitzilopochtli, was the god of war, while Tlaloc was the god of fertility and rain. When studying for the exam, Huitzilopochtli stuck in my head as the god of war, so I picked him. The prof said that in class he mentioned that Tlaloc also had militaristic aspects. 
Note that I'm not saying the prof is wrong objectively, only that our book makes no mention of Tlaloc being war-like and instead makes emphasis on fertility and life, being a beneficial god, which seemed totally opposite to war. When I sent my email I explained that I picked Huitzilopochtli because the book lists only him as the war god, but that I recognize my answer is only half-right due to the water reference, and that I feel that Tlaloc is also only half-right since he's not a war god.

Also, the prof agreed with me that the book was misleading, but said that I should've come to the lecture. Hence my question here focusing on whether the book should have any authority without getting into the details of the question itself.

profilepic.png
manpreet 2 years ago

My opinion -- as a university teacher for four years pre-PhD and eleven years post -- is that your story is balanced precariously on the border between "unfortunate" and "actionable". What is to be done about this probably depends a lot on your national and local university culture, the culture of your department, and even on the judgment of your own instructor.

Here is some advice about how to best deal with the situation:

I sent an email to my prof with the page number and the exact quote from the textbook that supports my answer.

That is already not the ideal strategy. This is a matter that requires some discussion, and email -- especially email exchanged between people who don't know each other well -- is not conducive to discussion but rather to one-sided statements of position, often of a nature which is more definitive, defensive or combative than a person would be in a face-to-face meeting. You should go to physically meet with your instructor. It is not too late to try to do so.

"In class I said that correct exam answer... This is an issue with any text and shows why class is so vital: Texts rapidly go out of date or (such as the broad text used for this course) demonstrate a lack of depth. Lectures are usually much more up to date."

That's a pretty good answer. If the textbook is incorrect, superficial or out-of-date on the point which was covered in the lecture, and if you did not attend the lecture, then you are showing that you did not receive and learn the information you were tested on.

Keep in mind that this is an Archaeology class, which in my unprofessional opinion really doesn't "go out of date" all that quickly.

Definitely don't say that again. This sentiment is indeed unprofessional. It is also ignorant and insulting: academia is about the progression of knowledge, not just keeping it preserved for posterity. Archaeology is no different from any other field in that manner.

The online lecture notes posted by the prof make no mention of the disagreement.

That is not definitive, but it makes me more sympathetic to your situation.

I was not present at the lecture.

That's bad. You have every right to expect that when you miss lectures you miss critical information. That's desirable, really: otherwise what's the point of lectures? By any chance did you contact the instructor and ask to be updated on what you missed? Did you get notes from some classmate that did not include this point? Either of these would mitigate your absence (the first more than the second).

Do professors have an obligation to recognize the assigned textbook as an authority in the context of the course?

No, of course not. On the contrary, they have the obligation to correct the textbook when they feel it is helpful and/or necessary to do so.

In my experience, when confronted with such a problem they typically go "Ok, fair enough, I'll give you the mark", but are they just being nice or are they supposed to do this?

I agree; "I'll give you the mark" is the more typical, nicer reaction. Not to do it is being a little callous, in my opinion. But it is unlikely that "they are supposed to do this", at least not officially. The instructor of a course has a certain amount of authority. This decision, although it may not be a "nice" one, seems to fall within that authority, at least in my experience.

He's not a senior prof (not even PhD yet), so do you think going to his superior would help?

At most universities I'm familiar with, someone who does not have a PhD is not a "professor" at all. But that probably doesn't really matter: what matters whether he is the "instructor of record" or a "teaching assistant". (Probably: in some places, one does in practice have more or less classroom authority according to one's academic rank and seniority.)

Yes, going to his superior might help. But you should think very carefully about this and have at least one face-to-face meeting with your instructor first. Before you do that:

Find out whether your answer was actually correct, or arguably correct.

If it is, you'll have much more of a leg to stand on. If it isn't, if push comes to shove...well, we mark the right answers right and the wrong answers wrong, don't we? Finally:

If I get this one extra mark it will bump me up 0.4 GPA for the course because I'm right at the cut-off.

This is the line that tipped me over a bit into recommending that you pursue the matter at least a little further. It is one thing to mark a question wrong because it is wrong. It is another thing to stand on this to the extent that it lowers your final course grade. There's a proportionality issue here: yes, you were apparently wrong to go with your textbook rather than the instructor. But were you that wrong?

It seems likely to me that some more senior personnel in the Archaeology department will feel the same way. If you can find such a person, then maybe they can influence your instructor. However, if you are very confrontational with your instructor then he may be inclined to stand on principle, even in the face of senior personnel. You really want to make changing the grade the easier, more palatable option for all involved.


0 views   0 shares

No matter what stage you're at in your education or career, TuteeHub will help you reach the next level that you're aiming for. Simply,Choose a subject/topic and get started in self-paced practice sessions to improve your knowledge and scores.