Proof for this answer

manpreet Best Answer 2 years ago

I am not sure whether this is offtopic. However, please read on.

A person whom I know has encountered a problem in the answer key published by CBSE, India. As their key challenging form contains a column for citation/proof, we have to find some authentic book which can be shown as the base of our claim.

I attach the question here, and I request you to verify the answer and suggest us some book/other ways to prove our challenge (She has checked the regular syllabus books, but didn't find something precise related to this problem).

Question:

Identify the minimal key for relational scheme R(A, B, C, D, E) with functional dependencies F = {A->B, B->C, AC->D}

The options are A, AE, BE, and CE

The key shows the answer is A and she says it is AE actually.

Please help us find some proof/way to challenge the key.

manpreet 2 years ago

A+ = {ABCD}

AE+ = {ABCDE}