Technology to transfer data with external system

manpreet Best Answer 2 years ago

We have an interface with an external system in which we get flat files from them and process those files. At present we run a job a few times a day that checks if the file is at the ftp location and then processes if it exists. I recently read that it is a bad idea to make use of file systems as a message broker which is why I am putting in this question. Can someone clarify if a situation like this one is a right fitment for the use of some other tool and if so which one? Ours is a java based application.

manpreet 2 years ago

The first question you should ask is "is it working?".

If the answer to that is yes, then you should be circumspect about change just because you read it was a bad idea. I've read that chocolate may be bad for you but I'm not giving it up :-)

There are potential problems that you can run into, such as files being deleted without your knowledge, or trying to process files that are only half-transferred (though there are ways to mitigate both of those, such as permissions in the former case, or the use of sentinel files or content checking in the latter case).

Myself, I would prefer a message queueing system such as IBM's MQ or JMS (since that's what they're built for, and they do make life a little easier) but, as per the second paragraph above, only if either:

• problems appear or become evident with the current solution; or
• you have some spare time and money lying around for unnecessary rework.

The last bullet needs expansion. While the work may be unnecessary (in terms of fixing a non-existent problem), that doesn't necessarily make it useless, especially if it can improve performance or security, or reduce the maintenance effort.